|
|
 |
|
|
|
Home > Features > Rosalind Franklin: She's Worth Another Look
|
Rosalind Franklin: She's Worth Another Look
|
|
| |
by Lisa Barton
Robert E. Lee High School
Tyler, Texas
|
|
| | "The Race"
If you were to ask my students about the history of the discovery of the structure of the DNA molecule, most would come up with the names of James Watson and Frances Crick. I, like most biology teachers, include the contributions of Rosalind Franklin with information about the other lively characters from "the race." But what do students remember about her after the unit on DNA is only a mist in their brains? Some remember her X-ray diffraction technique; others might say, "She's that lady who got her notes stolen."
The story of the race to uncover the structure of DNA has been told many times from many different perspectives. Rosalind Franklin's work began while she was at London's King's College. Franklin was known for her meticulous preparation of her DNA samples for X-ray diffraction photographs, and the picture of the B-form of DNA proved most valuable. Franklin was unhappy at King's College -- her personality clashed with her colleague Maurice Wilkins, which was further strained by the presence of Watson and Crick -- and she was eager to assume a new position at Birbeck College. She was in a rush to finish work on the X-ray diffraction experiments and to publish her results.
It is widely known that Watson and Crick, with the help of Wilkins, obtained data from Franklin's X-ray diffraction photos without her consent. Watson and Crick had a vision of the structure of DNA. It was incorrect, but they were close. With the insight they gleaned from Franklin's research, they were able to work out the details. Watson and Crick published their results in Nature in 1953; the same issue of the magazine carried Franklin's X-ray diffraction results. With her research concluded, Franklin moved on to Birbeck College to work on other biomolecules, leaving the controversy over the ethics of the situation behind her. Watson, Crick, and Wilkins received the Nobel Prize in 1962, after Franklin's death (the award is not given posthumously). Her X-ray diffraction photo was a crucial piece of evidence that led the other scientists to fame.
Even though I try to portray the race to uncover the structure of DNA and the controversy surrounding it in the most diplomatic way that I can, my students come away with one of two attitudes about Rosalind Franklin. Either they adopt James Watson's attitude toward her, that she was a mediocre scientist of little merit, or they get defensive about her and the fact that her notes were "shared" without her consent. Even though her contribution to the elucidation of the structure of the DNA molecule is Franklin's most famous work and is what put her name in biology textbooks, there is more to her career as a scientist that should be explored and celebrated.
Before and After DNA
Long before her dealings with Wilkins, Watson, and Crick, Franklin studied carbon and graphite microstructures. While earning her Ph.D. from Cambridge, she worked as an assistant research officer for the British Coal Utilization Research Association. Her research focused on the microstructures of various coal types to determine why gases and water could penetrate some types and not others. This research was important and timely. Charcoal had been used in gas masks during World War I as well as in those being used at the time in Britain. It was the early 1940s and Franklin, her family, and fellow students had lived through the Blitz. As a result of the ongoing threat, Franklin and other students carried gas masks to classes at Cambridge.
The focus on carbon and graphite research continued to a new job in 1947. Franklin worked in a laboratory in Paris, where she practiced and perfected the X-ray crystallography techniques that would later make her famous. During the middle and late 1950s, after her work on DNA's structure, Franklin continued her use of X-ray crystallography to examine the structures of virus particles. The main focus of the early research was the Tobacco Mosaic Virus (TMV). Her research led her to believe that TMV was a hollow tube of protein. She hypothesized that the RNA of this virus was single-stranded and helical. Her characteristic perfectionism in experimental procedure and technique led to the discovery that the RNA was actually embedded in the proteins and not contained only in the core as expected. The descriptions Franklin provided were incredibly detailed, including the angle of the location of the RNA relative to the axis of the virus. Franklin was passionate about her research and felt that it would lead to a greater understanding of viruses that plagued man. She expanded her research to include the polio virus and a potato virus, but her research was cut short due to ovarian cancer. She was extremely frustrated knowing her work on viruses was not completed. After several years of surgeries, radiation, and chemotherapy, Franklin died in London on April 16, 1958. Her research was presented at the 1958 World's Fair without her, receiving the accolades it deserved.
Another Look at the Woman
Rosalind Franklin deserves another look, not only as a truly interesting personality in the history of science, but as a woman as well. She loved fashion and theater and had a passion for the outdoors. Her favorite holidays involved hiking in the mountains of Europe. She was a perfectionist from an early age and wanted to be the best at everything she tried. Family members and friends knew she had high standards for herself and those around her, making her difficult to deal with at times. James Watson described her very harshly in his book, yet thought enough of Franklin to inquire about her after hearing of her illness. Even when she was extremely ill, she made sure her virus research group was financially taken care of through grants. She was well respected by her colleagues, who admired her courage and drive to work until her last days. Books on Rosalind Franklin give a different account of "the race" and of the woman. A new biography, Rosalind Franklin: The Dark Lady of DNA, was recently released and gives a fresh perspective on the personality and the work of this remarkable lady of science.
Sources
Maddox, Brenda. Rosalind Franklin: The Dark Lady of DNA. Harper Collins, 2002.
Sayre, Ann. Rosalind Franklin and DNA. New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1975.
Watson, James. The Double Helix: A Personal Account of the Discovery of the Structure of DNA. New York: Athenaeum, 1968 and London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson, 1981.
Lisa Barton is a biology teacher at Robert E. Lee High School in Tyler, Texas. She was the 2001-02 Teacher of the Year at Robert E. Lee and a finalist at the district level. A veteran teacher of 12 years, Lisa has taught all levels of biology. She has served as the science department chairman for six years, is involved in teacher training, and adores working with freshmen. This is her first article.
For more information about Rosalind Franklin visit...
|
|
|
|
|
|
Course Home Pages